Red Sox vs Yankees Predictions, Odds & Best Same-Game Parlay (June 9)

By George Nassios in MLB Baseball
Published:

- On Friday, June 9th, the Red Sox and Yankees meet up for the first time this season
- The Red Sox currently sit in last place in the ultra competitive American League East
- Find the Red Sox vs Yankees odds below, as we also offer up our best bets and a same-game parlay
Baseball’s best rivalry is renewed when the Red Sox (31-32, 14-16 away) begin a series with the Yankees(37-27, 20-15 home) on Friday, June 9th in the Bronx. It will be the first meeting between the squads this season as they are scheduled to face each other six times in the next 10 days.
First pitch of Friday’s encounter is set for 7:05 pm ET from Yankee Stadium with NESN and the YES Network providing the television coverage. Boston has been scuffling over the last few weeks, compiling a 5-12 mark in their last 17 games.
Meanwhile the Yankees, who were comfortable favorites in the AL East Division odds prior to the start of the season, are dealing with a few big injuries and are sitting 8.5 games back of Tampa for first. Below, you can see the Red Sox vs Yankees odds for this game, as well as our prediction and same-game parlay picks.
Red Sox vs Yankees Odds
Team | Moneyline | Runline | Total |
---|---|---|---|
Boston Red Sox | +160 | +1.5 (-140) | O 8 (-110) |
New York Yankees | -183 | -1.5 (+120) | U 8 (-110) |
As the only team with a record under .500 in the division, the Red Sox are +160 underdogs for the opener versus the Yankees in a game that features an over/under total of eight runs. The over is 6-1 in the last seven meetings between these two sides in New York.
Smoky skies due to fires from up north caused the postponement of a Yanks game earlier this week, but if anything throws a wrench into Friday evening’s affair with the Red Sox it might be rain. Forecasts are saying there will be a 60% chance of precipitation at some point during the game.

SPORTSBOOK
Odds as of June 8th at Bet365. Claim a Bet365 bonus code to wager on the Red Sox vs Yankees.
Boston vs New York (AL) Probable Pitchers
Drafted by the Bronx Bombers back in 2017, Garrett Whitlock makes his first career start at Yankee Stadium in this one. He is just a couple weeks removed from coming off the injured list with an elbow injury that forced him to miss over a month of action.
Mixed bag from Garrett Whitlock. Pitched better than his line indicates.
Defense didn’t do him any favors and made him work extra in some tough spots.
Continued to miss bats with 5 Ks. Didn’t have the same feel for his changeup… also walked 2.
— Tyler Milliken ⚾️ (@tylermilliken_) June 3, 2023
In five starts this campaign, he’s lasted more than five innings just once. With a middling bullpen, the Red Sox are hoping the 26-year old can stretch out his starts a little more. The righty battled against the division leading Rays last week, but his defense let him down as he left after surrendering four runs in four and two-thirds.
At least he’ll be able to avoid the most fearsome bat in any of the MLB starting lineups, as Aaron Judge is on the injured list with a toe sprain and won’t be available for this series.
Whitlock vs Cole Stats
2-2 | Record | 7-0 |
5.61 | ERA | 2.82 |
1.29 | WHIP | 1.13 |
.283 | OBA | .213 |
4.0 | SO/W Ratio | 3.0 |
Even after giving up five earned in back-to-back outings to close out the month of May, Gerrit Cole is still one of the top contenders in the Cy Young odds this season, sporting a perfect 7-0 record and 2.82 ERA so far.
He may not be excited about facing the Red Sox though. Out of the 15 teams he has made at least 15 starts against in his career, no team has hit more homers or scored more runs against the Cole Train than Boston.
On top of that, it looks like he’ll be going against a side that may be more motivated than usual to do damage in the teams first meeting of the season after his teammate, Nestor Cortes, threw some shade at the Red Sox earlier this week. Funny enough, Cortes is out with an injury and won’t have to deal with Boston.
Nestor Cortes had this to say about the Yankees-Red Sox rivalry 👀 pic.twitter.com/2WgBNvAkFo
— FOX Sports: MLB (@MLBONFOX) June 8, 2023
Red Sox vs Yankees Same-Game Parlay Picks
Although Cortes might not think so, it’s always exciting when the Red Sox and Yanks hook up. The Yankees have owned the rivalry of late, taking the last six contests between the two last season, including a four game sweep at Yankee Stadium in late September.
However, I don’t know if it was smart for Cortes to add fuel to the fire. It’s not wise to underestimate the pride of this Red Sox organization, especially at this early juncture of the year. In every game when they faced Cole last season, the score went over the projected run total in the MLB odds.
Red Sox vs Yankees Same-Game Parlay
Team | Odds |
---|---|
Boston Red Sox +1.5 | -140 |
Over 8.5 Runs | -105 |
Same-Game Parlay Odds | +240 |
For the season, Boston is the second best team to make money on when picking them to go over the run total, providing a return of investment of over 12% and exceeding the betting line in 58.7% of their contests.
Red Sox vs Yankees Prediction
Due to a postponement in their schedule on Wednesday, the Yanks were forced to play a doubleheader on Thursday. They are the better squad, but there are a lot of factors at play that point to a Red Sox upset.
Boston has banged up Cole in the past. Last year’s home run champ and the second betting favorite in the MVP odds this season, Judge, is out with injury. New York might be tired after playing two the day before and Cortes has provided the Bosox with some bulletin board material.
Our prediction is that the Red Sox deal Cole his first loss of the season, so take Boston at +160 on the moneyline to draw first blood in the rivalry this season.
Pick: Boston Red Sox Moneyline (+160)

Sports Writer
George has had a lifelong love affair with sports and studying sports statistics since he was a kid. He graduated from Ryerson University with a Bachelor's Degree in Journalism and has worked in the sports & media industry ever since in various roles from writer to producer.