Mike Trout Odds-On Favorite to Win 3rd AL MVP Award

By Ryan Sullivan in MLB Baseball
Updated: April 27, 2020 at 9:45 am EDTPublished:

- Mike Trout’s 2019 MVP odds have improved from +220 to -150 in the last two and a half weeks
- Will he win his third American League MVP title this season?
- Are there better value bets on the board?
It’s not easy to live up to a 12-year, $432 million contract right out of the gates. However, Mike Trout has looked like he’s worth every penny. He currently leads the MLB in OPS at 1.508 and is second in slugging at .933. He also has five home runs and 12 RBI through 30 at bats.
2019 AL MVP Odds
Player | 2019 AL MVP Odds |
---|---|
Mike Trout (Angels) | -150 |
Mookie Betts (Red Sox) | +800 |
Aaron Judge (Yankees) | +800 |
Alex Bregman (Astros) | +1500 |
Gary Sanchez (Yankees) | +2000 |
Odds taken on 04/08/19.
Will Trout Take Home Another AL MVP Title?
Yes, the stats listed above are very nice to look at, but again we must warn you, it is very early. If Trout was going to stay atop the list though, this would be the year to put some dough behind him.
This is what Mike Trout does when the Angels get men on base for him 😱His fourth HR in three games, traveling 458 feet
(via @MLB)pic.twitter.com/DcjkuTKssV
— SI MLB (@si_mlb) April 6, 2019
You could argue that he was robbed last season by Mookie Betts (+800), but Betts did end the year with a better average and one more RBI. Those are two stats that Trout should be able to easily eclipse the Red Sox outfielder in this season.
With the loss of James Paxton and Edwin Diaz in Seattle, Trevor Cahill in Oakland, and Dallas Keuchel and Charlie Morton in Houston, he’ll have a much easier divisional go at the dish – which accounts for 76 games of the Angles’ schedule. In other words, it’s a big deal.

Trout has the shortest 2019 AL MVP odds by a landslide thanks in large part to his ability to hit the long ball. Since his magical 41-homer 2015 season (as seen above), his dinger per game average (let’s call that DPGA) has been very consistent (0.18-2016, 0.29-2017, 0.28-2019). If he can stay healthy, he undoubtedly can have a huge season.
Are There Better Value Bets Out There?
In short, maybe. In the last sentence of the preceding Trout propaganda we emphasized “If he can stay healthy”. That’s a big deal. Trout has missed 70 games over the past two seasons. His stats have still endured the test and while he did take home a Silver Slugger award last year, he hasn’t seen an MVP since 2016 because of his health.
Mike Trout has missed 70 games over the past two seasons.
Enter Aaron Judge (+800) and our dark horse pick Alex Bregman (+1500) to swoop in. Judge has better pitching in front of him this season which should ease the pressure. Meanwhile, in Houston, Bregman faces almost the polar opposite situation and will be relied upon even heavier for bat support.
After going 1-for-15 vs. the Rays to open the season, Alex Bregman has hit safely in each of the Astros’ last six games, going 11-for-20 while reaching base in 16 of 26 plate appearances (.615 OBP).
— Brian McTaggart (@brianmctaggart) April 8, 2019
The Astros mound weakened through the offseason and with the loss of Marwin Gonzalez and Evan Gattis, they’ll need Bregman to pull off some serious magic with the stick. If he can, you could be sitting pretty betting on our dark horse pick.

Sports Writer
Ryan is what you call a seasoned vet. It's been nearly 13 years and he has hosted three sports radio talk shows, two football television shows, two sports podcasts, released his first book in 2012, had his own ESPN E:60 documentary shot, and was the first inductee to ESPN's Hall of Fans.